Wednesday, February 16, 2011

AIDS: Music to the ears?

When it comes to art, I have a very open mind. Theatre is probably one of my favorite mediums for story. I can appreciate the realistic to the fantastic, musical and none, classic and avante-guarde, when it comes to witnessing performances live on stage. If there is anyplace you can get away with almost anything in the name of artistic representation, it's the theatre. One of the most well-known depictions of HIV is that shown in RENT, a musical about the "bohemian" lifestyle, independence, urban life, and HIV. Or is it?
I honestly did not appreciate the movie RENT, but when I finally saw it on stage at UCF, as one of the last people I knew who like musicals to have seen it, it opened my heart to the different, fun-to-listen-to (mostly) score, funny dialogue, and interesting balance of drama and comedy. Despite some crazy characters, jokes, and over-the-top acting that is traditional of musicals, one of the later scenes includes the lovable drag-queen/homosexual character dying from AIDS complications.
I recall shedding tears during the scene, but while things like this create sympathy about the disease, do they also perpetuate stereotypes? Yes, it's true that AIDS is an issue in the gay community and urban areas, but that isn't the whole story. Someone who is only exposed to artistic portrayals of AIDS such as this could come away with that idea. At the same time, does the fun of a musical or any show counteract the sympathy it evokes?
Consider the movie Team America. The most popular song from the comedy goes something like, Everyone has AIDS, AIDS, AIDS!" with the action figures dancing around, driving an untrue message into the heads of viewers like a big joke. Personally, I found the movie funny, but at the time I did not stop and think about these implications. When I asked what readers of this blog thought about comedic takes on HIV, such as that in the South Park episode, most people expressed some concern about insensitivity or misrepresentation.
In my opinion, you can't sensor art, whether it's your idea of art or not. You cannot expect one piece to show anything from every angle. Even an autobiography, written by the person whom its about as a firsthand account, leaves bits and pieces unaccounted for, shifting the focus on certain things like a filter. Should we expect to take the humor out of anything that somebody, somewhere may find offensive? The only thing we can do is combat this with education while enjoying the arts. It is unfortunate that some people take things too literally because they don't have the knowledge to do otherwise, but that is why we need to do what we can to spread awareness.
A recent comment from Teach also addressed the role humor plays in coping. I have to agree. As someone with a chronic illness, I find laughter to be the "best medicine" but kind of natural. Doctor's visits become such a routine that to take it too seriously would mean to be depressed nearly every day. I realize that it's serious and feel the pain, but it is not reason not to find some comedy in everything. For instance, I have become even more scatter brained and clumsy since getting more sick. I have "brain fog" and am often dizzy, making my coordination and balance off. I was already someone who experienced relatively frequent falls and spills, but now it's just ridiculous, and I constantly lose things. People make fun of me, but if I didn't take it lightly it would only add more stress. Even when I am hurting, I laugh at myself for moving like an elderly person or not being able to get out of bed like I am lazy. For me, there is no other way to take it.

Did You Know

RENT is widely regarded in the theatrical community and elsewhere as a huge awakening for the public regarding AIDS. I have heard personal testimonies about the show in which people believe it is a good teaching tool and plan to have their children see the show someday. I was able to find little information on the attitudes of actual HIV positive people regarding the show.
With my own illness, I know that I often find different accounts easy to relate to, even if they aren't entirely the same. When I hear songs written about lupus or see it on TV, I am grateful that is mentioned at all and am reminded that I am not alone. I look forward to finding out how individuals who are HIV positive feel about this kind of stuff through interviews.

7 comments:

  1. I also saw the play RENT at UCF. It was a wonderful play and it gave me a whole new outlook on what it was about. Honestly, I never really knew what the play was about. All I knew was the song The Seasons of Love, but I didn't know it was from this play. The only reason I went to watch it was because I took Theater and it was one of the plays we had to go see. I must say it was great and I would love to see it again. It was informative, loving, comical, and a all around must see.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jackie,

    I'd like to start by saying how much I appreciate you commenting on my blog and a thank you for your kind words about my attributes. Maybe one day I'll run into you; you sound like a great person to know. Anyone could learn a thing or two from you.

    Unfortunately, I am unfamiliar with RENT. I have only heard of it. I must say, your thought process is incredible. I cannot disagree with your opinion about seeing any one piece of art from every angle. Someone, somewhere, will always find a way to critique it. That is what makes the world so interesting. Everyone has their own opinions and beliefs. Besides, what's a world without creativity? Although, it is unfortunate that Team America and South Park may be misrepresented, but I think everyone at some point in time show wrong judgment for something (maybe to a lesser degree).

    I do wish you the best, as always, with your condition and of course I look forward to next week. Thanks again!

    -Dominick Iannelli

    ReplyDelete
  3. Strong points Jacquelynne! I completely understand where your coming from when you state that you enjoy people mentioning a personal issue that you are going through. It feels nice to know that some people are out there paying attention to something that is not only sensitive to you but evokes quite a bit of emotion.

    While I personally have not seen rent I am more than interested in watching it because of this class and just getting a more unique angle. I am actually heading out to rent it right now. Thanks!

    -Abel Berhane

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello Jacquelynne,
    I enjoyed the movie RENT, I thought it was pretty good. But unfortunately I can not get myself to watch it again, it was to sad. One of the thing you said really grasps my attention. "Should we expect to take the humor out of anything that somebody, somewhere may find offensive?". Why should we? Everyone is unique, we don't have the same taste in food, clothing, mate, or art. So the fact that someone don't find me funny won't make me stop joking around and have a good time. See, that's the problem people need to start appreciating art, meaning you don't have to like it, just appreciated it.

    Lydie Joseph

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It is interesting how I am not the only one aware of the South Park episode depicting HIV as something humorous. It is definitely not something to joke about due to its impact worldwide. Anyways, I was unaware that the play RENT had a depiction of HIV in its plot. A close friend of mine loved the movie, but i had always thought it was because she was a dancer and a performing arts major. I might have to check it out myself.

    Great post about laughter being a cure by the way. I think laughter is very important when it comes to lifting people's spirits up.

    -Aguiling, M.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I saw the stage play at the Bob Carr and I thoroughly enjoyed it. I realize that the arts can use the freedom of expression to try to get their point across and knowing that I can watch a movie, or see a play and realize that although I might not do it that way, they had that freedom.

    There are studies on the role of laughter and wellness. You might want to look some of them up.

    ReplyDelete